The Benicia Independent ~ Eyes on the Environment / Benicia news & views

The Benicia Independent ~ Eyes on the Environment / Benicia news & views

Search
Skip to content
  • Coronavirus
    • CA.gov COVID-19 data for Solano County
    • Excellent daily summary at CovidActNow
  • Benicia Black Lives Matter
    • Benicia Black Lives Matter – Our Voices
    • Benicia’s Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Initiative
    • Anti-racism letters in the Benicia Herald
  • BENICIA – WHERE TO WRITE & CALL!
  • ARCHIVES
    • Kari Birdseye for Benicia City Council 2022
    • 2020 Benicia Election
      • The BenIndy on our 2020 Election
      • Valero smears Steve Young to promote it’s preferred candidate
      • Valero PAC Financial Disclosures
    • ISO
    • CRUDE BY RAIL
      • About Crude By Rail
        • Resources
        • Marilyn Bardet interviews
        • Valero CBR Background
      • CBR – Take Action Now!
        • Day After the NEXT BIG ONE – Take Action!
      • CBR – Local Media Coverage
      • CBR – Links
      • Stop the oil trains – Poetry, Song, etc.
      • CBR – CBR Official Project Documents
        • Valero appeal to City Council (and STB)
        • Final EIR
        • REVISED EIR
        • Draft EIR and Mitigated Negative Declaration
      • CBR – 2016 Project Review
        • Formal Comments by Benicians for a Safe & Healthy Community
        • 2015 – Public comments DEIR, RDEIR
        • Highly critical reviews at close of DEIR public comment period
        • 2014 – Public comments DEIR
        • 2013 – Public Comments MND & Scoping
      • Kamala Harris letters
  • RogerStraw.com
  • ABOUT THE BENINDY
Bakken Crude, Crude By Rail, Derailment, Emergency Readiness & Response, Oil spill, Spill, Spill prevention and response, Tar sands crude

Forecast: derailment every other year if oil train terminal is built

November 24, 2015 Roger Straw

Repost from McClatchyDC
[Editor: Reporter Curtis Tate of McClatchy DC was honored last week with a National Press Foundation award for his reporting on crude by rail. The Benicia Independent has reposted many of Tate’s reports, and joins the NPF in honoring him for his many excellent contributions. – RS]

Analysis forecasts derailment every other year if oil train terminal is built

HIGHLIGHTS
•  Wash. state facility would receive 4 trains a day
•  Just one fire department in state said it was ready
•  BNSF among clients of firm that wrote spill study

By Curtis Tate, November 24, 2015
More oil trains could bring more oil train derailments to Washington state, a draft environmental impact statement predicts.
More oil trains could bring more oil train derailments to Washington state, a draft environmental impact statement predicts. Bellingham Herald

WASHINGTON – A proposal to build the largest oil train terminal in the Pacific Northwest could result in a derailment every two years and an oil spill from a derailment once every 12, according to a draft analysis by a Washington state agency.

The document, released Tuesday, indicates that most fire departments along the oil trains’ rail route are not prepared for a spill or fire that could accompany a derailment. Out of the 12 departments that responded to the survey request, only one indicated its firefighters are trained and equipped for such an incident.

Further, only half the departments said they knew the locations of BNSF Railway’s specialized firefighting equipment closest to their jurisdiction. And while three-quarters of them reported having access to personal protective equipment, firefighting foam and foam applicators, only a quarter said they had access to oil spill containment booms.

The draft environmental impact statement from the Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council said that BNSF would bring four oil trains a day to the Vancouver Energy facility at the Port of Vancouver, Wash., with the loaded trains mostly following the path of the Columbia River and the empty trains returning east via Tacoma, Auburn and Stampede Pass.

With those four daily trains, carrying 100 or more cars each of either light crude from North Dakota or diluted heavy crude from western Canada, the agency forecast “a derailment incident might occur once every two years with a loaded train, and once every 20 months with an empty train.”

The document noted, however, that not all derailments would result in a spill.

Tina Barbee, a spokeswoman for Vancouver Energy, said the company was reviewing the document and “will be able to address specific issues and respond to more detailed questions over the coming weeks.”

Courtney Wallace, a spokeswoman for BNSF, said the railroad had trained 800 firefighters in Washington state this year, and that included giving them the location of BNSF’s specialized firefighting resources.

She said BNSF has equipment and personnel staged in Everett, Seattle, Longview, Wishram, Pasco and Spokane.

“We will continue to work with first responders to ensure they have information about BNSF’s resources,” Wallace said.

EDITORS: STORY CAN END HERE

There have been seven derailments of oil trains in North America this year that have resulted in spills or fires. Though none of those events took place in Washington state, derailments in West Virginia, Illinois, North Dakota and Montana released hundreds of thousands of gallons of crude oil.

The rail spill analysis portion of the Washington state draft document was written in part by three consultants who are former employees of BNSF and its predecessor, Burlington Northern. In addition to the state agency for which they prepared the analysis, their clients include BNSF and the Port of Vancouver.

Neither the state agency, nor its consultants could be reached to comment late Tuesday.

Wallace, the BNSF spokeswoman, said she knew of no work or input from the railroad on the rail spill analysis.

Read McClatchy’s award-winning coverage of oil trains


Read more here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/national/economy/article46350165.html#storylink=cpy

 

Read more here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/national/economy/article46350165.html#storylink=cpy

 

Auburn WABakken crudeBNSF RailwayColumbia RiverCrude by RailDerailmentEmergency Readiness & ResponseEnergy Facility Site Evaluation CouncilEverett WALongview WAoil spillPacific NorthwestPasco WAPort of VancouverSeattle WASpillSpill prevention and responseSpokane WAStampede PassTacoma WATar sands crudeVancouver Energy ProjectWashington StateWishram WA

Post navigation

Previous PostThree derailments are three too manyNext PostOil train safety concerns cast shadow over cross-border rail deal

SUBSCRIBE TO BENINDY NEWS & VIEWS

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,085 other subscribers

The occasional BenIndy Newsletter

Sign up for the OCCASIONAL Benicia Independent newsletter.  The newsletter comes out once a month on average, by email.

CLICK HERE to join over 1,300 other Newsletter subscribers…

Buy a BenIndy hat, mug, t-shirt…

Enjoy the cool designs…
your dollars will support the BenIndy!

For safe and healthy communities…

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Ariana Martinez for Benicia School Board, April 11 Special Election January 24, 2023
  • Housing Update should be adopted with “Environmentally Superior Alternative” January 22, 2023
  • Benicia Historical Society joins others in calling for ‘Environmentally Superior Alternative’ January 22, 2023
  • Protect our historic districts and places on the National Register – the highest level recognition of historic significance January 19, 2023
  • Refinery Air Watch – Webinar intro to new website showing detailed data on Valero Benicia and refineries across U.S. January 19, 2023
  • Seeno vs. Seeno feud casts shadow over huge East Bay land deal January 7, 2023
  • Susannah Delano: Recruiting a Legislature that looks like California (finally) December 17, 2022
  • Birdseye and Scott take oath of office as members of Benicia’s City Council December 16, 2022
  • Governor Newsom Convenes Special Session to Hold Oil Industry Accountable for Price Gouging December 2, 2022
  • Vallejo says it ‘inadvertently’ destroyed records in five police shooting investigations December 2, 2022
  • Benicia Election: Solano County certifies final results November 30, 2022
  • Meeting tonight – What’s the Future of Benicia’s North Side? November 29, 2022
  • Local non-profit sues City of Benicia – Development threatens Civil-War era buildings and grounds November 29, 2022
  • Benicia Schools honor Ruby Bridges November 22, 2022
  • Benicia Council election: Scott and Birdseye are in November 18, 2022

Archives

Proudly powered by WordPress