Category Archives: Democracy under attack

Over 70,000 People Detained in 225 Concentration Camps, With Plans to Double Them: Why Isn’t This a National Emergency?

ICE is shopping for giant warehouse-style facilities they can retrofit into what they euphemistically call “detention centers.”…

By Thom Hartmann, The Hartmann Report Feb 4, 2026

As people testified before Congress yesterday about the brutality and violence they’d suffered at the hands of ICE, that massive paramilitary organization was shopping for giant warehouse-style facilities they can retrofit into what they euphemistically call “detention centers.”

Cable news people call them “prison camps” or “Trump prison camps,” but look in any dictionary: prisons are where people convicted of crimes are held. As Merriam-Webster notes, a prison is:

“[A]n institution for confinement of persons convicted of serious crimes.”

Jails are where people accused of crimes but still waiting for their day in court are held, as Merriam-Webster notes:

“[S]uch a place under the jurisdiction of a local government for the confinement of persons awaiting trial or those convicted of minor crimes.”

But what do you call a place where people who’ve committed no criminal offense (immigration violations are civil, not criminal, infractions)? The fine dictionary people at Merriam-Webster note the proper term is “concentration camp”:

“[A] place where large numbers of people (such as prisoners of war, political prisoners, refugees, or the members of an ethnic or religious minority) are detained or confined under armed guard.”

The British originated the term “concentration camp” to describe facilities where “rebel” or “undesirable” civilians were held in South Africa during the Second Anglo‑Boer War (1899–1902) to control and punish a rebellious population.

They were facilities where the “bad elements of society” were “concentrated” into one location so they could be easily controlled and would lose access to society and thus could not spread their messages of resistance against the British Empire.

The Germans adopted the term in 1933 when Hitler took power and created his first camp for communists, socialists, union leaders, and, by the end of the year, Hitler’s political opponents. They Germanized the phrase into “Konzentrationslager” and referred to the process of their incarceration as “protective custody.”

The first camp was built at Dachau just weeks after Hitler became Chancellor in 1933, and by the end of the year there were around 70 of them operating across the country.

When Louise and I lived in Germany in 1986/87, we visited Dachau with our three children. The crematoriums shocked our kids, but even more so because this was simply a “detention facility” and not one of Hitler’s death camps (which were all located outside Germany to ensure deniability).

The ovens at Dachau were for those who had been worked to death or killed by cholera or other disease, much like the 35+ people who’ve recently died in ICE’s concentration camps.

When American friends would visit us and we’d take them to Dachau (we lived just an hour up the road) they’d invariably be surprised when I told them that by the time of the war there were over 500 substantial camps and an additional few hundred very small ones all over the country.

“How could the people not know what was going on?” they’d ask.

The answer was simple: the people did know. These were where the “undesirables,” the “criminal troublemakers,” and the “aliens” were held, and were broadly supported by the German people. (It wasn’t until 1938, following Kristallnacht, that the Nazis began systematically arresting and imprisoning non-political Jews, first at Buchenwald, and Sachsenhausen.)

By the end of his first year, Hitler had around 50,000 people held in his roughly 70 concentration camps, facilities that were often improvised in factories, prisons, castles, and other buildings.

By comparison, today ICE is holding over 70,000 people in 225 concentration camps across America, and Trump, Homan, Miller, and Noem hope to more than double both numbers in the coming months.

In Tennessee, The Guardian reports that Miller has been coordinating with Republican leaders to create legislation that would turn every local cop, teacher, social worker, and helper in the state into an official agent of ICE and criminalize efforts by cities to refuse cooperation. It also makes it a felony crime to identify any of ICE’s masked agents or disclose conditions within the concentration camps to the public.

Germans didn’t have the benefit of warnings from a fascist history they could look back on; much of what Hitler did took them by surprise, as I’ve noted in previous articles.

In 2026 America, however, operating with the benefit of historical hindsight, entire communities are rebelling at Trump’s effort to beat Germany’s 1933-1934 prisoner numbers.

In city after city, Americans are organizing to deprive ICE of their coveted spaces, putting pressure on companies not to sell and on cities and counties not to permit any more concentration camps.

Because immigration violations are labeled “civil,” people in ICE concentration camps are stripped of many of the normal constitutional protections that apply to people in criminal incarceration. This has created a legal black hole that ICE and the Trump regime exploit, where indefinite imprisonment, abuse, and medical neglect flourish with little to no oversight or accountability.

Human rights organizations like the ACLU describe pervasive patterns of abuse in ICE detention: hazardous living conditions, chronic medical neglect, sexual assault, retaliation for grievances, and extensive use of solitary confinement.

Detainees who have committed no crime other than being in the United States without documentation report being shackled for long periods, packed into freezing, overcrowded cells under constant fluorescent light, and denied hygiene and timely care. Meanwhile, GOP-aligned private prison companies are making billions off the program.

Inspections and oversight are inconsistent: one recent investigation found that as detentions and deaths surged in 2025, formal inspections of facilities actually dropped by over a third. ICE regularly refuses to allow attorneys, family members, and even members of Congress to access their concentration camps; the issue is now being litigated through federal courts.

History shows us that once a nation builds a mass detention apparatus, it never remains limited to its original targets. Future generations of Americans — our children and grandchildren — won’t ask us whether ICE followed civil detention statutes: they’ll want to know why we allowed concentration camps to exist in America at all.

Germany’s concentration camps didn’t start as instruments of mass murder, and neither have ours; both started as facilities for people the government’s leader said were a problem. And that’s exactly what ICE is building now.

History isn’t whispering its warning: it’s shouting.

Louise’s Daily Song: “Count the Camps”


If you believe democracy needs defending, subscribe to The Hartmann Report. Free or paid, your support matters. Share this post to help wake more people up.

The song that was inspired by this article is here.
My reading this article as an audio podcast is here.
My newest book, The Last American President: A Broken Man, a Corrupt Party, and a World on the Brink is now available in bookstores nationwide.
You can follow me on Blue Sky here: https://bsky.app/profile/thomhartmann.bsky.social

Stephen Golub: From the Streets of Minneapolis to the Streets of Benicia

Candlelight Peace Walk –
….this Sunday  Feb 1 at 6 pm

By Stephen Golub, Jan 30, 2026

Download – click to enlarge.

A “Candlelight Walk for Peace and Unity” will take place Sunday, February1  at 6 pm, starting at the City Park Gazebo (at First Street, near Military West). As the informal group of Benicians organizing the event put it, in emails and online:

We’ll gather at the gazebo and stroll together down to the water and back, creating space for reflection, connection, and shared intention for peace and unity in our community.

At a time when many are feeling uncertainty and division, this walk offers a simple way to come together and remember our shared humanity.

This is a family/dog-friendly event. Electric candles are encouraged. Feel free to bring signs with your favorite peace quote.

All are welcome.

Electric candles will be available for free at the Gazebo, shortly before the walk.

We may each view the Walk in our own way. I see its inspiration as the need for our community to come together and do something positive, in the wake of the fatal shootings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis at the hands of federal agents.

As I contemplate the gathering, I’m also  considering another message, one that went out to America a few days after Pretti’s January 24 death: Bruce Springsteen’s angry anthem, “Streets of Minneapolis.” It commemorates not just Good and Pretti, but the people of Minneapolis marching in near-zero temperatures to stand up for their neighbors and to stand against Donald Trump and his militarized occupation of their town.

Yes, occupation. It’s correctly characterized that way by virtue of the government dispatching 3,000 federal agents to a city whose police force numbers 600 and to state where a dozen police chiefs’ press conference reported “endless complaints” concerning federal officers’ behavior  and “that city employees and off-duty officers had been illegally stopped on the basis of their skin color.”

Clearly, the threat is not confined to one city. As  summed up by one account of the mushrooming expansion of U.S. Immigration and Enforcement (ICE):

“Trump has turned ICE into a sprawling paramilitary that roves the country at will, searches and detains noncitizens and citizens without warrants, uses force ostentatiously, operates behind masks, receives skimpy traininglies about its activities, and has been told that it enjoys ‘absolute immunity.’ He more than doubled the agency’s size in 2025, and its budget is now larger than those of all other federal law-enforcement agencies combined, and larger than the entire military budgets of all but 15 countries.” [Emphasis added.]

But don’t take my word for what this is all about. It’s about the  opinions of thousands of leading principled conservatives, including one appointed by George W. Bush and who served during Trump’s first term: “I helped to establish DHS [Department of Homeland Security, of which ICE is a part] in 2002 and 2003 and later had the homeland security portfolio as a White House Counsel and served as General Counsel of the Department. I am enraged and embarrassed by DHS’s lawlessness, fascism, and cruelty. Impeach and remove Trump—now.”

It’s about a conservative federal judge, who was appointed to the bench by W and who clerked for a Republican judicial hero, the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia. He’s decried the fact that ICE’s  violations of nearly 100 federal judicial orders this month has been more than “some federal agencies have violated in their entire existence.”

Which brings us back to Bruce and the “Streets of Minneapolis”:

Oh our Minneapolis, I hear your voice crying through the bloody mist
We’ll remember the names of those who died on the streets of Minneapolis

Yet, piercing that bloody mist, there’s also angry inspiration, pointing to what we can do to push back:

Their claim was self-defense, sir, just don’t believe your eyes
It’s our blood and bones and these whistles and phones against Miller and Noem’s dirty lies

Sadly, there will be plenty of opportunities to decry and combat those lies down the line.

But this evening, we walk for peace and unity on the streets of Benicia. True to the organizers’ admirable intentions, our community can come together to share our humanity in a respectful manner that even kids can participate in and appreciate.

Tonight, I’ll walk  with these words from a different Springsteen song in my head and heart, and in honor of Good, Pretti and the brave people of Minneapolis:

May your strength give us strength
May your faith give us faith
May your hope give us hope
May your love give us love


Benicia resident and author Stephen Golub, A Promised Land

[sta_anchor id=”below” /]Stephen Golub writes about democracy and politics, both in America and abroad, at A Promised Land: America as a Developing Country.

…and… here’s more Golub on the Benicia Independent

Back to top

NEXT NO KINGS DAY – Saturday, March 28

SAVE THE DATE.
BUT DON’T SIT BACK AND WAIT!

https://nokings.org


MEMORIES: BENICIA’S JUNE 2025 NO KINGS RALLY:

In America, we don’t put up with would-be kings.

Our peaceful movement is only getting bigger and stronger. “NO KINGS” is more than just a slogan—it’s the foundation our nation was built upon. Born in the streets, carried by millions in chants and on posters, it echoes from city blocks to rural town squares, uniting people across this country to fight dictatorship together.

The president thinks his rule is absolute. But in America, we don’t have kings, and we won’t back down against chaos, corruption, and cruelty. Grow our movement and join us.

A core principle behind all No Kings events is a commitment to nonviolent action. We expect all participants to seek to de-escalate any potential confrontation with those who disagree with our values and to act lawfully at these events. Weapons of any kind, including those legally permitted, should not be brought to events.

More at https://www.nokings.org/

So hard to stay hopeful – good words for 2026

Dear BenIndy friends – The following came to me in an email. Like so many of you, I’ve started deleting many or most of these good resistance pitches without even reading them. Most are looking for money – and even when not, almost all are depressing. This one isn’t. It’s a good analysis with a few excellent suggestions. (You might recall that Choose Democracy is the organization we promoted in Benicia back in 2020 as we helped organize against a Trump/MAGA coup.) Read on…
– Roger Straw, The Benicia Independent

Breaking Norms to Look Strong

Friend,

Happy New Year. And it’s clearly going to be quite the ride.

I drafted a New Year’s message that started, “Trump is the weakest he has been since getting in office. Weak dictators are dangerous and will lash out as their friends co-sign atrocious norm-busting actions to appear strong and in charge. We’re likely to see escalated violence even as his support drains away.”

We are seeing this with Trump’s kidnapping of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro.

A President unilaterally ordering bombing in Venezuela and the forcible kidnapping of a sitting head of state is clearly illegal under both international law and the U.S. Constitution, as noted by the UN. It’s not coming from a place of strength, coherence, rationality, kindness, anti-drugs, or human rights…

Yes, this is about oil. Yes, Stephen Miller wants to demonize Latin Americans. Yes, Marco Rubio wants to break Cuba’s economy and is using Venezuela as a stepping stone for that. Yes, all of this is a distraction that less than 1% of the Epstein files have been released, the fifth anniversary of January 6th, and economic turmoil.

But Trump is not a strategist or playing any long game. He wants power and control. This is his sense of naked, raw power.

The rest of us are left processing reasons and rationales, scratching our heads trying to assess the meaning and end goals. Elites, billionaires, and his corrupt gang are going to exploit this moment.

But for Trump it’s just about being the biggest bully on the playground. He’s running the authoritarian’s favorite move: creating a caricatured villain to take on–and hoping the country will see him as a savior.

Trump wants the world to believe he cannot be restrained by anyone. That strength emanates from people fearing that he will break any norm. That’s why there was no declaration of war, no imminent self-defense claim, and no authorization from Congress as required by the War Powers Resolution. The norm-breaking is the point. Legal scholars are clear this crosses a bright red line. This is not law enforcement; it is an illegal war crime.

For Trump, this is the same underlying story we’ve seen: hoping that his friends will see him as strong and that his opponents will grow fearful.

Our test through 2026 is to help people unhook from this story. Those who tell us that the President cannot be stopped are giving him what he wants: a story of unrivaled, unstoppable power.

But 2025 proved his limitations. Courts stymied and slowed many maneuvers. Trump lost control over the national guard in many cities (by the Supreme Court, no less). He couldn’t censor Jimmy Kimmel. He couldn’t control the Epstein story. And whenever he began to lose, he would change the subject.

So in 2026 he will continue to make horrible, violent, murderous moves — not all of which we will be able to stop in the immediate. Our job in 2026 is to continue withdrawing people’s support for those policies, not only in words but in deeds.

The Pillars of Support

We’ve been teaching over the last year that authoritarians take advantage of institutions’ unwillingness to push back. Trump doesn’t execute laws, give judicial rulings, write headlines, build roads, invade countries, kidnap residents, tear down the West Wing. He orders others to do it — and if they refuse to comply, an authoritarian’s power to give orders becomes useless.

That’s what happened when Trump ordered Indiana State Republicans to gerrymander the state. Hoosiers across the political spectrum said no — in town halls, in calls, in protests, in direct actions. Even after Trump escalated with personal threats and people acting on his behalf engaged in acts of violence, Indiana politicians said no — they would not accede and they would not comply.

Or another example right now: Minneapolis faces threats of 2,000 federal agents descending on their city in what appears to be a Chicago-style waged campaign of raids and terror targeting Black, Brown and immigrant communities. Residents of Minneapolis have shown much grit in escorting kids, confronting federal agents directly, and pooling funds to support residents who fear for their safety and are unable to work. But they did more than focus on Trump and federal agents — they expanded their targets to include hotels who are putting ICE up. The campaign may have already notched its first win: “Minnesota Hilton cancels ICE agents’ hotel reservations,” blares the headlines from The Guardian. (The situation now remains uncertain, with the national chain insisting it’s “resolved” this dispute.)

The point is we’ve been sapping Trump’s support over the last year — and we have to continue growing that. It helps to not just focus on Trump — but on those pillars of support, too. Here are some of those pillars with respect to Venezuela:

Congress

If you’re looking for immediate actions, colleague Ash-Lee Henderon offered a direct one: contacting your leaders in Congress. The Constitution is explicit: Congress decides questions of war. If it abdicates now, it sets a precedent that will be used again — and again.

A bill is moving this week to stop further action in Venezuela — so the timing is right now. Her suggestion:

  • If you’ve got 10 minutes: contact your two U.S. Senators
  • If you’ve got 20 minutes: contact your two Senators + your House Representative
  • If you’ve got 30 minutes: add Senate Foreign Relations Committee leadership or members you have ties to.

Call the U.S. Capitol switchboard: (202) 224-3121. You can find direct info for congress people at https://5calls.org/issue/trump-venezuela-extrajudicial-murder/.

Military personnel

In a just society, many people involved in planning and executing an illegal war would face accountability. Senator Mark Kelly and others famously made a video reminding service members of their oath to disobey unlawful orders. Section of Article 92 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice is clear — servicemembers must not follow orders that are “manifestly unlawful.”

Veterans have been organizing. In this moment, Common Defense continues to mobilize veterans and military families to defend the Constitution and oppose forever wars: https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/defend-the-constitution-end-forever-wars

Oil companies

No one benefits more from Trump’s actions in Venezuela than oil companies. These are hard targets — and unavoidable ones. War after war has been fueled by the same corporations that poison our air, destroy communities, and accelerate climate collapse.

Venezuela’s oil — the largest reserves in the world — has been a geopolitical prize — and a recurring justification for pressure, sanctions, covert action, and now open force.

After many decades in which U.S. and European companies dominated extraction, Venezuela formally nationalized its oil industry in 1976. This followed earlier reforms in the 1960s that steadily increased Venezuelan control and royalties. The move was broadly popular inside the country and made Venezuela a central player in OPEC.

At the moment, Chevron is the only remaining US oil company operating in Venezuela. They have over 400 locations across the US, from gas stations to refineries to corporate offices. These are prime locations for future actions as they stand to benefit quickest.

Other companies, like Exxon, are eyeing ways to get their hands on Venezuelan oil — but like much of this rapidly unfolding situation, taking oil from Venezuela is not straightforward.

We expect to see more soon — a 1-day wildcat consumer strike has been called for January 8th. The ask is easy enough: no buying oil or gas on January 8th. https://bit.ly/StrikeThePump. More targeted actions will follow!

International solidarity

The U.S. cannot do this alone. Pressure from other countries matters. One concrete demand: countries should refuse to buy stolen Venezuelan oil.

Canada, Mexico, and the Netherlands are some of the largest buyers of US oil. They share some responsibility for the US engagement in another imperialist venture. A boycott — or even the threat of one — could pressure both governments and oil companies, especially as firms already express concern about entering Venezuela.

Mainstream media

The media is playing a role sanitizing the kidnapping of a head of state. Words like “capture” — used in almost all US press — understate the gravity of abducting a country’s leader. They have not accurately named the US’s piracy in stealing oil shipments.

Largely, the press remains quick to quote Trump and slow to fact-check his lies. No, this is not about drugs — Venezuela does not smuggle fentanyl into the US. No, the US is not “reclaiming stolen oil” — this is a factually deficient framing that ignores history.

Journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones writes, “So many in media are ill-equipped to interview officials about what’s happening because they begin with the presumption of legitimacy and don’t know enough about history or U.S. foreign policy to foment intelligent pushback and hold officials accountable. The questions begin with WILL regime change be successful, not how is it legal or ethical to orchestrate a coup and who are we to decide when leadership must go and who are we to believe we have rights to a sovereign nation’s resources.”

(You can follow real journalists like her and Marsia Kabas.)

All these — and other pillars — are upholding the authoritarian regime. They keep it normalized, legitimized, flush with resources and protection. 2026 is about continuing to strip that back.

I want to affirm again this analysis: Trump is the weakest he has been since getting in office. Weak dictators are dangerous and will lash out as their friends co-sign atrocious norm-busting actions to appear strong and in charge. We’re likely to see escalated violence even as his support drains away.

Resistance is growing. He is not invincible. More and more people are not being taken in by the lies and his regime’s utter disregard for life. The hill is high to climb, but each step that you can take matters.

So for 2026, don’t give in to the fear.

Warmly,

Choose Democracy
https://choosedemocracy.us/