Category Archives: Benicia City Council

Cathy Bennett: Valero’s “current intent” is anyone’s guess

If Valero closes, or not … Benicia can hold them accountable. This is not the end of the world.

By Cathy Bennett, April 24, 2025

Cathy Bennett, Benicia

My thanks go to Steve Golub in his recent article outlining the broader perspective and potential reasons for Valero’s “possible” closer. As always, Steve is clear and concise in explaining a very complicated situation. In the wake of Valero’s sudden announcement there is a lot of finger-pointing going on, and his article wisely advises a mindful step back to see the bigger picture.

I for one, do not believe that Valero is actually going to close. I think Valero is stacking up its options in a strategic move to give itself as much wiggle room as possible for the tough decisions it must now make, due to a variety of reasons, the least of which is the
watered-down ISO. I also believe Valero benefits tremendously by these scare tactics to the public (and Benicia City Council) at the very time when decisions are forthcoming regarding fees and fines for the ISO.

The timing of Valero’s announcement, and the reckless manner it threw its employees and the city of Benicia under the bus, strikes me as a crude thumb to the nose. Another example that Valero has never been “a good neighbor”. That said I would urge everyone to resist panic. There are many layers to this onion. We must peal back each layer one at a time to expose the true underbelly of what is before us. By staying focused and examining each step, Benicia will develop a solid strategy to move forward. Benicia must hold Valero accountable for what ever decision it ultimately makes. That includes clean up of the 400 acres of potentially toxic contamination of waterfront property if it plans to close.

This is not the end of the world, nor the demise of our beloved Benicia. I trust our city council to think this through carefully, not over-react, and not capitulate to Valero’s threats. This is one more piece of evidence of the bully behavior we have been dealing with for decades.

Cathy Bennett
Benicia resident for 25 years

Larnie Fox: Open letter to our Benicia City Council and staff

Thank you for placing the health and safety of Benicians above other concerns

By Larnie Fox, April 23, 2025

Benicia resident and artist, Larnie Fox

Dear Mayor, City Council members, and Chief Chadwick,

I am so proud of our City Council and staff!

In light of the recent announcement by Valero to “idle, restructure or cease refining operations”, it is more important than ever to have an Industrial Safety Ordinance in place. In spite of significant pressure and threats from Valero, and at great political cost, you placed the health and safety of Benicians above other concerns. Bravo! And thank you.

I think that Valero’s decision had little to do with our new ISO, but probably did affect the timing of their announcement.

It looks like what made them decide to change their operations next year was the regulatory atmosphere in California, the expense of fixing their hydrogen leak, and the $82M fine from the Air District. California is moving away from fossil fuels, and the company could see the writing on the wall.

What made them announce their decision now? My guess is it was a desire to blame you and your constituents’ measured effort to finally monitor and regulate the refinery’s ongoing release of toxins, and to stir up community resentments.

If they sell or restructure, the ISO will be important to monitor and regulate whatever activities occur on their site. If they shut it down, then we will need a plan in place to assure a “just transition” ~ aka a good clean-up of a very toxic site. With some long-term and visionary thinking, something good may yet come out of this.

The ISO will also be important to regulate the dozen or so other industries that work with dangerous chemicals in town, especially Valero’s other little refinery, the asphalt plant.

It took courage to lead our little town to stand up against big oil, but you did it, and we did it.

Thank you!

Larnie Fox, Benicia

SF Chron: Benicia to increase oversight of Valero refinery after major pollution problems

Benicia City Council passes Industrial Safety Ordinance in unanimous vote

The Valero refinery in Benicia, show in 2019, will be subject to tighter oversight from its host city going forward. Paul Chinn/S.F. Chronicle

San Francisco Chronicle, by Julie Johnson, April 2, 2025

Months after Bay Area regulators handed a record-setting fine for pollution violations to oil giant Valero Refining Co.’s Benicia facility, city leaders voted to establish stronger oversight over refinery emissions.

The Benicia City Council unanimously passed regulations Tuesday creating a new air quality monitoring program and requiring the refinery and other entities handling hazardous materials to promptly report emissions.

Vice Mayor Trevor Macenski said they hope to “foster a resilient business environment within Benicia while ensuring that our citizens don’t all need inhalers.”

The city’s plan is modeled after a similar ordinance in Contra Costa County, which for more than two decades has empowered county health officials to investigate potential emissions problems at three oil refineries, including Chevron, across the Carquinez Strait.

The Solano County city has lacked similar oversight power for Valero. Benicia leaders have been frustrated in recent years by revelations of emissions problems at Valero and a lack of notification from agencies charged with pollution oversight. The Bay Area Air Quality Management District waited three years to inform Benicia residents after agency staff discovered Valero was spewing illegal amounts of cancer-causing gases and chemicals into the air and had done so for 16 years.

Council Member Kari Birdseye, who campaigned on more refinery oversight when she was elected in 2022, said in an interview that the air district’s $82 million fine was a “wake-up call” for Benicia.

“Our community wants to know exactly what’s going wrong and how we can ensure those types of things don’t happen again,” Birdseye said.

The ordinance, which takes effect 120 days after the vote, allows the city to investigate pollution issues when other agencies, such as the Bay Area air quality district, state or federal agencies, aren’t conducting investigations. It also requires facilities such as the refinery to report potentially hazardous releases to the city.

The vote was unanimous despite strong opposition from some business representatives and Valero executives, who previously called the ordinance “governmental overreach.”

Valero refinery officials did not immediately respond to a request for comment this week.

The ordinance would also pertain to a dozen other businesses in the city, including the city’s water and wastewater treatment plants, paint company Sherwin-Williams, a chemical decontamination firm, cork supply company, and several manufacturers.

Under a current contract with the city, Valero provides the city a base amount of $331,320 annually. The ordinance would terminate that contract and replace it with fees based on how much hazardous material Valero handles. That applies to other industrial facilities that fall under the ordinance as well. The city’s new plan starts with no fees for the smallest operators and increases up to $386,260 annual fee for the largest.


Photo of Julie Johnson

Julie Johnson is a reporter with The Chronicle’s climate and environment team. Previously she worked as a staff writer at the Santa Rosa Press Democrat, where she had a leading role on the team awarded the 2018 Pulitzer in breaking news for coverage of 2017 wildfires.

Tues. APR 1 – Attend Benicia City Council

BENICIA ISO TO BE VOTED ON APRIL 1
Agenda and how to Zoom In…

BISHO.org

Benicia City Council – Council Agenda for April 1
IN PERSON, 6 PM:
Benicia City Hall, Council Chambers
250 East L Street, Benicia, CA 94510
VIA ZOOM, 6 PM:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88508047557?pwd=cHRsZlBrYlphU3pkODcycytmcFR2UT09
Meeting ID: 885 0804 7557
Password: 449303
Phone: 1 669 900 9128

CALL TO ATTEND – By the Benicia Industrial Safety and Health Ordinance citizens group (BISHO)

Benicia, CA (March 28, 2025) – On Tuesday, April 1, Benicia City Council will meet to discuss and conduct its final vote on the draft Industrial Safety Ordinance (ISO) that will help protect Benicians against potential fires, explosions and toxic emissions connected to the Valero Refinery and other facilities. The meeting will be at Benicia City Hall, 230 East L Street, Benicia, beginning at 6 p.m.

“Because this is the final up-or-down vote on the ISO, we are urging supporters to attend to show support, either in person or by Zoom,” said Terry Mollica, a member of Benicia Industrial Safety and Health Ordinance (BISHO), a citizens group formed in 2023 to advocate for the passage of a strong Benicia Industrial Safety and Health Ordinance.  “This is our last, best chance to establish an ISO that will get Benicia a seat at the table to protect the health and safety of our kids, our seniors and everyone else in our wonderful city.” BISHO has more than 250 supporters, with membership and website visits growing as more refinery incidents occur. Benicia is the only Bay Area refinery town without an ISO.

Benicia City Council voted in January 2023 to begin the process of developing a draft ISO to ultimately be presented to City Council for vote. Since that time, a City Council subcommittee, led by Council Members Terry Scott and Kari Birdseye and Fire Chief Josh Chadwick, have conducted multiple meetings with stakeholders, citizens, experts in industrial emissions, environmental groups, other Bay Area refinery cities and many others to gain feedback as to the best ISO for Benicia.

On March 4, City staff, led by Chief Chadwick, presented the draft ISO to Council and the public. After presentations by many community members, Valero and other industrial organizations to be affected by the ISO, Council voted unanimously to move forward with the draft, calling for a second reading and final vote.

“Our citizens group is thrilled that the ISO is close to becoming a reality,” said Mollica.  “Along with local health and environmental advocates, we have spent years calling for tighter regulations to protect citizens from dangerous industrial emissions that impact air quality and the health of Benicians. We are finally near the finish line and are so grateful that City Council has supported this effort.”

For safe and healthy communities…