SF Chron: Benicia to increase oversight of Valero refinery after major pollution problems

Benicia City Council passes Industrial Safety Ordinance in unanimous vote

The Valero refinery in Benicia, show in 2019, will be subject to tighter oversight from its host city going forward. Paul Chinn/S.F. Chronicle

San Francisco Chronicle, by Julie Johnson, April 2, 2025

Months after Bay Area regulators handed a record-setting fine for pollution violations to oil giant Valero Refining Co.’s Benicia facility, city leaders voted to establish stronger oversight over refinery emissions.

The Benicia City Council unanimously passed regulations Tuesday creating a new air quality monitoring program and requiring the refinery and other entities handling hazardous materials to promptly report emissions.

Vice Mayor Trevor Macenski said they hope to “foster a resilient business environment within Benicia while ensuring that our citizens don’t all need inhalers.”

The city’s plan is modeled after a similar ordinance in Contra Costa County, which for more than two decades has empowered county health officials to investigate potential emissions problems at three oil refineries, including Chevron, across the Carquinez Strait.

The Solano County city has lacked similar oversight power for Valero. Benicia leaders have been frustrated in recent years by revelations of emissions problems at Valero and a lack of notification from agencies charged with pollution oversight. The Bay Area Air Quality Management District waited three years to inform Benicia residents after agency staff discovered Valero was spewing illegal amounts of cancer-causing gases and chemicals into the air and had done so for 16 years.

Council Member Kari Birdseye, who campaigned on more refinery oversight when she was elected in 2022, said in an interview that the air district’s $82 million fine was a “wake-up call” for Benicia.

“Our community wants to know exactly what’s going wrong and how we can ensure those types of things don’t happen again,” Birdseye said.

The ordinance, which takes effect 120 days after the vote, allows the city to investigate pollution issues when other agencies, such as the Bay Area air quality district, state or federal agencies, aren’t conducting investigations. It also requires facilities such as the refinery to report potentially hazardous releases to the city.

The vote was unanimous despite strong opposition from some business representatives and Valero executives, who previously called the ordinance “governmental overreach.”

Valero refinery officials did not immediately respond to a request for comment this week.

The ordinance would also pertain to a dozen other businesses in the city, including the city’s water and wastewater treatment plants, paint company Sherwin-Williams, a chemical decontamination firm, cork supply company, and several manufacturers.

Under a current contract with the city, Valero provides the city a base amount of $331,320 annually. The ordinance would terminate that contract and replace it with fees based on how much hazardous material Valero handles. That applies to other industrial facilities that fall under the ordinance as well. The city’s new plan starts with no fees for the smallest operators and increases up to $386,260 annual fee for the largest.


Photo of Julie Johnson

Julie Johnson is a reporter with The Chronicle’s climate and environment team. Previously she worked as a staff writer at the Santa Rosa Press Democrat, where she had a leading role on the team awarded the 2018 Pulitzer in breaking news for coverage of 2017 wildfires.

Another Benicia protest – UPDATE: Now EVERY Sunday 12-1pm, First & Military

EVERY SUNDAY
AT THE BENICIA CITY PARK
12 NOON – 1 PM
UPDATE! Now on EVERY Sunday!
(formerly every 2nd Sunday)

City Park – MAP

I learned somewhat belatedly that Benicia has TWO ongoing protests, both in City Park (near the Gazebo) at the corner of First & Military Streets. I’ve posted previously about the every-Thursday protest. This other one is EVERY SECOND SUNDAY, and has been organized by Benician Heather Pierini.

If you CAN’T make it to one of the April 5 HandsOff! protests, maybe you can stop by City Park on Sunday April 6 around noon!

Background:

This is from Heather’s email:

I organized the Benicia protests starting Sunday, March 9th.  My impetus was disbelief at the continued disdain for the rule of law by the Trump Administration and Elon Musk/DOGE.

I feel strongly that everyone needs to see someone standing up against these absurd policies and senseless budget cuts that only hurt our community.

Everyone who comes to the protests have their own personal point of view about why they are protesting.  Generally, the major categories are Women’s Rights, support for Ukraine, support for established laws and rules of government, resisting fascism, oligarchy and, well, just all of this.  After this week’s debacles, I’m sure we will see a boost in participation.

We will be meeting every second Sunday at the Benicia City Park between 12-1 PM.  The next date is Sunday, April 6.

I made a facebook event as reminders here: https://fb.me/e/4AcMUospx

Roger Straw
The Benicia Independent

April 5 – Massive Day of Protests near Benicia – Find one and show up!

Click here for protest times & locations near Benicia, CA.

Things have gotten even worse than we could ever have imagined. EVERYONE, if you possibly can, show up for one of these events to give voice to the nation and the world, that it’s simply not ok to for our government to defund the Education Department, to defund and deplete public health, social security and veteran outreach, to deport people without due process, and yes, to SINK THE ECONOMY with massive worldwide tariffs.  …among so many other horrors. It’s time we ALL speak up!

Find nearby protest events here…

About the April 5 Hands Off protests:
Donald Trump and Elon Musk think this country belongs to them. They’re taking everything they can get their hands on, claiming anything standing in their way is illegal, and daring the American people to stop them.
On Saturday, April 5, we’re taking to the streets nationwide to fight back with a clear message: Hands off!

  • Indivisible.com has made it clear: A core principle behind Hands Off! is a commitment to nonviolent action. We expect all participants to seek to de-escalate any potential confrontation with those who disagree with our values, and to act lawfully at these events.
  • This event is being organized by Indivisible, MoveOn, Public Citizen, Stand Up America, and the Not Above the Law Coalition in support of the Hands Off day of action and future actions. [from mobilize.us]

WHY “HANDS OFF”?

 

View on Threads

 

EVERYONE SHOW UP ON APRIL 5!

For safe and healthy communities…